Sunday 10 November 2013

Review: The Walking Dead: Season 4, Episode 4 – Indifference

Spoilers! 

It’s another great episode of The Walking Dead this week, as emotional tension is rife amongst two different groups on the road. Whilst Daryl, Michonne, Tyreese and Bob go on the hunt for medical supplies, Carol and Rick effectively do the same but depart ways in one of the show’s most controversial and emotional decisions. 

From the off, this week marks a welcomed and refreshing decision to take action away from the claustrophobic prison walls and into the wild. The suburban street and veterinary college make effective backdrops for both the emotional tension and intense walker set pieces. As Daryl, Michonne, Tyreese and Bob continue to stock up on medical supplies, they naturally find themselves in one or two life-threatening situations. The dark corridors and unfamiliar territory throughout the college truly heighten the intensity and suspense, and overall create moments of thrilling entertainment. Yet it also feels that such surroundings make the perfect accompaniment for the group’s emotional dynamic.

Dark shadows, hidden surprises, murky waters – all elements of their perilous journey and representative of battles with their emotional baggage, be it with The Governor, alcoholism or mourning the loss of a loved one. As they fight their way through each obstacle, a little more about their state of mind is revealed. Yet this journey was by no means cathartic, as an overwhelming presence of anger and vengeance remain and will no doubt become exacerbated once they notice Carol’s disappearance... and the reason for it.

Rick takes it upon himself to also go on a supply run this week, heading for houses in a typical suburban street. After her admittance to killing Karen and David, he feels uncomfortable leaving Carol behind at the prison, so instead brings her along with him. In a similar fashion to Daryl et al., their surroundings aptly reflect their emotional confrontation. In a well lit, open-street space Rick is just as open about his opinion of Carol’s actions.

After deliberating her reasoning and witnessing the occasional moment of heartfelt compassion, Rick makes the controversial decision to exonerate her from the group. Providing her with supplies and a car, he firmly requests that she go elsewhere, find a new group or survive it alone. The ramifications of this decision could be monumental, given the groups high opinion of Carol. Not to mention, Rick’s farming habits have signaled a firm end of the ‘Ricktatorship’, leaving tough decisions to be made by the council, a group of leaders with whom he hasn't consulted. 

Right or wrong decision, and whatever the consequences may be, it is certainly a shame to see Carol leave (for now at least). Not only because the development of her character has been a joy to watch (and thinking about it, it’s amazing just how far she has come), or because quite possibly, we believe Rick made the wrong decision, but because Melissa McBride has been a continuous joy to watch. It is safe to say she left on a high note, with a performance wonderfully encapsulating an emotional dichotomy of strength and desperation.As she drives away, it's hard not to hope for a reunion in the future. 

Two groups, two emotional confrontations - yet whilst Daryl et al., provide the majority of the action in a refreshing and effective setting, Rick and Carol take centre stage. Their emotional confrontation provides the episode with its most compelling, heartfelt and through-provoking material, resulting in a decision that will no doubt incur a reaction far from indifferent in the upcoming weeks.


What were your thoughts on this episode? Post a comment! 

No comments:

Post a Comment